What is confusing to ELLers is that the verb have has two forms in the present tense: To have to be something=To have got to be something. I'm not the downvoter, and I agree with you that some explanation should be added while downvoting. Please note: have got is used in speech, not in writing. I saw a song of Eric Clapton in which he says "Why Has Love Got To Be So Sad". In English, there are two present forms of the verb have when it means to have an obligation or be necessary (to have to do or be something or to have got to do or be something) or possession or ownership (to have or have got something). To subscribe to this RSS feed, copy and paste this URL into your RSS reader. or "Why love has to be so sad"? In Concert is a live double album, recorded by Derek and the Dominos in October 1970 at the Fillmore East and released January 1973. The structure of Why Has Love Got To Be So Sad is completely fine, because it's a question. to be the original one) for the lyrics: "Why Does Love Got to Be So Something has got to be [something]. Some examples here. ("Why does love get to be so sad") rather than past form (got). This kind of structure is a little difficult to me to understand as an non native English speaker. Does learning the same spell from different sources allow it to benefit from bonuses from all sources? I have got to go now. Have got is an alternative form of the present tense, used in speaking: to have or to have got. Well, I knew what it means "I have got to do sth", but in this case the structure of "whay has love got..." is the difficult thing. The best way to interpret this is to assume that have got to means must. How to manage a team member who is away from computer most of the times? When I updated the answer the proper usage of have got to, I forgot to remove indeed that reference. By the comments here I saw that there are another version (that seems Clapton used a diminutive 5-watt tweed Fender Champ during the sessions, which has grown to legend since. Why Does Love Got To Be So Sad This song is by The Allman Brothers Band and Eric Clapton and appears on the compilation Crossroads Guitar Festival 2013 (2013). Why does love got to be so sad. Love has to be so sad. - statement and mix up the two forms. By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy. This song is by Derek and the Dominos and appears on the album Layla and Other Assorted Love Songs (1970) and on the compilation Sounds of the Seventies: Guitar Power (1992). Why does love happen to be so sad? - statement “Why Does Love Got to Be So Sad?” is a song by the band Derek and the Dominos from their 1970 album Layla and Other Assorted Love Songs. - statement. English Language Learners Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for speakers of other languages learning English. Any way to watch Netflix on an iPad Air (MD788LL/A)? How can I handle a PC wanting to be a "twist" villain? I think Why Does Love Got to Be So Sad is completely wrong, or at least, I'd say that is something very informal in spoken English (perhaps American English), but it's anyway grammatically incorrect. interrogative sentence in present simple tense should come infinitive Why has love got to be so sad? To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers. She has to be kidding. How important is the gate threshold voltage on a MOSFET, Convert from VGA 9 pin to RCA (manually - old machine). She has got to be kidding. [Third person singular, has got]. Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience. I have to go now. Also, I gave have/has got to be kidding because in English there is often another verb after have/has got/must. Meaning: have to be. Why does love have to be so sad? In colloquial AmE,they make that: Why does something got to be so sad? You are simply seeing light touching your eyes (masturbation addiction). - statement Did a computer error lead to 6,000 votes switching from Joe Biden to President Trump? It only takes a minute to sign up. When you use have got to, you're saying that something is necessary or must happen in the way stated in the sentence. \ Love [does] happen to be so sad. In the question, Eric Clapton is wondering, in other terms: Why must love be so sad? What circumstances could lead to city layout based on hexagons? I'd expect to say "has got love to". Why Does Love Got to Be So Sad? The majority of the songs on Layla and Other Assorted Love Songs were products of Clapton and Whitlock's collaboration, which produced six of the nine originals on the recording; five covers fleshed out the balance. Take also into account that song lyrics don't always have a 100% grammatically correct English. Thanks! Sad", and for this version is even more not understood, since after an I'd expect him to say "has got love to" if he wants to say "why love must be so sad". Meaning of “Why Has Love Got To Be So Sad”, Feature Preview: New Review Suspensions Mod UX, Creating new Help Center documents for Review queues: Project overview, Meaning of “to tie so. Make a minimal and maximal 2-digit number from digits of two 3-digit numbers. So this means, Love happens to be so sad. down” in sad song lyric. Another example is here (question form part). to have to be something can also be said as: to have got to be something. After seeing the edited question: Turning right but can't see cars coming (UK). Thanks for contributing an answer to English Language Learners Stack Exchange! In the question, Eric Clapton is wondering, in other terms: Why must love be so sad? Why Has Love Got To Be So Sad What couldn't be so easy to you understand is the usage of have got to. Does meat (Black Angus) caramelize just with heat? Effect of touchdown on angle of attack, tailwheel vs tricycle. What is the word used to express "investigating someone without their knowledge"? rev 2020.11.12.37996, The best answers are voted up and rise to the top, English Language Learners Stack Exchange works best with JavaScript enabled, Start here for a quick overview of the site, Detailed answers to any questions you might have, Discuss the workings and policies of this site, Learn more about Stack Overflow the company, Learn more about hiring developers or posting ads with us. How to make this illumination effect with CSS, 90's PC game, similar to "Another World" but in 3D, dark, purple, locked inside a prison. - question To back up @hobbs, it's even right there in the video title and description. In the far future would weaponizing the sun or parts of it be possible? What is the meaning of “about” in “Love isn't all about flirting…” and “Love is about…”? This line could have been written in any of the other two ways given above as well. Honestly not sure where the "has" comes from. - statement Love [does] have to be so sad. What couldn't be so easy to you understand is the usage of have got to. When you use have got to, you're saying that something is necessary or must happen in the way stated in the sentence. @Lambie Yes, indeed when I first read the sentence I mixed up present perfect with the usage of have got to. site design / logo © 2020 Stack Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under cc by-sa. For this reason, have and the subject (love) change position: Why has (1st part of have got to) love (subject) got to (2nd part of have got to) be so sad? Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers. The three sentences above all mean the same thing. How would Earth turn into debris drifting through space without everything at its surface being destroyed? By the comments here I saw that there are another version (that seems to be the original one) for the lyrics: "Why Does Love Got to Be So Sad", and for this version is even more not understood, since after an interrogative sentence in present simple tense should come infinitive ("Why does love get to be so sad") rather than past form (got). Is there a puzzle that is only solvable by assuming there is a unique solution? Well, I knew what it means "I have got to do sth", but in this case the structure of "whay has love got..." is the difficult thing. what is meaning of ''one'' and ''has got'' in this statement? Stack Exchange network consists of 176 Q&A communities including Stack Overflow, the largest, most trusted online community for developers to learn, share their knowledge, and build their careers. FWIW the song is actually "Why does love got to be so sad", not "has". Why has something got to be so sad? In the simple interpretation of words, does it mean (in other words) to ask "Why love happens to be so sad?" Clicking the down arrow without giving any explanation is always so helpful... [not the dv] have got to be is not present perfect and [so easy for you to understand]. By using our site, you acknowledge that you have read and understand our Cookie Policy, Privacy Policy, and our Terms of Service.

Arts And Crafts Supplies Online Australia, Agave Dream Coffee Ice Cream, Barron's Ap Calculus 15th Edition Pdf, Used Razer Phone 2, Us Itunes Album Chart, Reclaimed Timber Benchtops, Daawat Biryani Recipe, Mexico Population 2070, Tv Shows For Parents, I Feel Like We Are Drifting Apart Letters, Famous Social Scientists, Common Lisp Windows, Reduced Instruction Set Computer Architecture, Slow Cooker Rice And Vegetables, Colour Pewter Grey, World Trade Solutions, Ora Organic Customer Service, Peach Bubly Discontinued, Internal Structure Of The Earth, Amazon Website Colors, Alberta Dornan Parents, Zeta Function Approximation, Homemade Cockroach Killer, Drive Fast Synonym, Iv Dosage Calculator, Business Plan Sample, Ps4 Vs Ps5 Specs, Plain Chicken Soup Recipe, Klimt Water Sprites, Clos Maggiore Restaurant Vs Conservatory, Cool Out Matthew E White Genius, Dhl Ocean Freight Market Update: April 2020,